Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton Sues TikTok for Sharing Minors' Personal Data in Violation of Texas Parental Rights
In a significant legal move, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has filed a lawsuit against TikTok, accusing the social media giant of violating the privacy rights of minors and breaching the state’s laws designed to protect parental authority. This lawsuit comes amidst increasing scrutiny of TikTok's data collection practices and its handling of user privacy, particularly in regard to minors.
Compliance Hub
Overview of the Lawsuit
The lawsuit, announced on October 9, 2024, alleges that TikTok illegally harvested and shared sensitive personal data belonging to minors without obtaining proper parental consent, a direct violation of Texas' laws concerning data privacy for children. Paxton's office claims that TikTok's practices undermine parental rights by making it difficult for parents to monitor or control the data collected about their children. The complaint specifically focuses on TikTok’s handling of geolocation data, biometric information (such as facial recognition and voiceprints), and browsing history, which could potentially expose minors to heightened risks online.
My Privacy Blog
The lawsuit asserts that TikTok violated several Texas laws, including the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act (DTPA), which prohibits businesses from engaging in false, misleading, or deceptive acts. Additionally, it argues that the company's failure to provide sufficient transparency about its data collection policies and disregard for parental oversight breaches state privacy protections. The Attorney General is seeking significant fines and a court-ordered injunction to prevent TikTok from continuing these practices.
Compliance Hub
TikTok's History of Privacy Concerns
This lawsuit marks the latest development in a long-standing series of privacy controversies involving TikTok, particularly concerning its handling of children’s data. TikTok, owned by Chinese company ByteDance, has previously faced global criticism over its data-sharing practices, with allegations that the platform shares data with Chinese authorities and other third parties, although TikTok has repeatedly denied these claims.
In the U.S., the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) fined TikTok $5.7 million in 2019 for violating the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) by collecting personal information from children under the age of 13 without parental consent. Since then, the company has taken steps to enhance its child safety features, including rolling out family pairing modes and age-appropriate privacy settings. However, Paxton’s lawsuit suggests that these measures may not go far enough to satisfy the privacy protections outlined by Texas law.
Texas' Response to TikTok's Practices
Texas has been one of the leading states in challenging major technology companies over data privacy issues. Attorney General Paxton has previously taken legal action against tech giants like Google and Meta, accusing them of violating user privacy and antitrust laws. His office has been particularly focused on enforcing laws that protect the digital privacy of Texas children, reflecting broader concerns from parents and policymakers across the country.
Paxton’s lawsuit emphasizes that parents should have control over what data is collected from their children and who has access to it. The lawsuit argues that TikTok deliberately obscured its data collection practices, preventing parents from fully understanding the risks their children face on the platform. Moreover, it suggests that TikTok’s vast data collection capabilities, coupled with its failure to properly verify age and parental consent, represent a clear violation of state law.
Broader Implications for Big Tech
The outcome of this lawsuit could have significant implications for how social media platforms handle user data, especially for minors. If Texas prevails, TikTok could face steep penalties and may be forced to overhaul its data collection and privacy practices, not only in Texas but potentially across the U.S. This case could also spur other states to examine their own privacy laws concerning minors, leading to further legal challenges against TikTok and similar platforms.
In addition, the lawsuit adds to the growing national conversation about how to regulate Big Tech. Lawmakers and advocacy groups have long called for stricter regulations on tech companies, especially those with large youth user bases like TikTok, Instagram, and Snapchat. Paxton’s lawsuit highlights the tension between state and federal regulations and could influence future federal privacy laws aimed at protecting minors online.
What’s Next?
As this case moves through the courts, it will be closely watched by both privacy advocates and tech companies. For TikTok, this lawsuit adds to the mounting legal challenges it faces as it tries to navigate increased regulatory scrutiny, particularly from U.S. authorities concerned about its connections to China.
Parents in Texas and beyond are likely to pay attention as well, as this case could redefine how social media companies are held accountable for safeguarding the privacy and security of young users.
TikTok has yet to respond to the lawsuit, but the platform is expected to fight the allegations, arguing that it has complied with existing privacy laws and made substantial efforts to protect minors. Regardless of the outcome, this case marks a pivotal moment in the ongoing battle over user privacy in the digital age.
